ca18 vs. sr20 vs. rb20 vs. ka24-t
i've heard there are advantages of each. here's what i've come up with so far.
ca18 stronger block- able to take more boost more potential cheap easy install rev happy weight advantage over ka and rb but... small displacement old weaker than rb and sr sr20 bigger displacement than ca18 easy install a lot of potential (less than ca18 tho) weight advantage over ka and rb but... expensive due to popularity rb20 straight 6 (kick ass) cheaper than sr20 but... heavier than all others-might throw off balence of the car hard install ka24-t no swap needed parts available easily in the US but... limited to 6-7psi w/o rebuilding expensive reliability is an issue i'm leaning toward either a ca18 or sr20. any opinions? i'd also like to see what the supercharger kit for the ka24 (by unstable hybrids) is going to be like before making any final decisions. |
Heres some reasons the SR is better than the CA or RB:
SR has a higher hp potential than a CA. Highest hp I've seen outta a CA is around 400+ whp, SR can go around 600. The CA weighs more than the SR. The CA has very little low end. Can't find parts easily. Really old. And well the RB would just be a pain in the ass. Ok the KA-T vs. SR is really tough there very different, but potential is equal. |
rb=bulletproof bottom end
rb isnt that much heavire then sr ca=cheap;) |
i've heard that the CA has a stronger block and therefore can take more boost. is this wrong?
|
the CA has a more aggressive cam profile then the SR. and the cams are a direct swap in.
the sr and ca have good strong internals. i couldnt tell you exactly how much better is between the two. my main concern is the RB series. i personally like the CA better then the SR but there arent a ton of parts for it in the US like the SR. |
Originally posted by rudeboy my main concern is the RB series. |
:music:
|
both CA and SR make gobs of power, but thats full on race. ive seen CA18s with 6-700hp, and SRs with 900hp.
|
yeah both engines can make retarded amounts of power.
but look what you have to spend/ do to make it. once your there it'll always come down to serious maintnance to keep it reliable. i dont know about yall but with 600 under my "happy foot" something is bound to break whoops |
Originally posted by rudeboy :music: |
huh????:confused:
|
The CA is a good choice as an engine. It has a cast iron block, and yes with stock internals the CA can handle more boost. Up to 20psi. I believe the differences in the head that you were talking about rude have to do with the cams. The CA has 8 lobes per cylinder vs. the 4 lobes per cylinder of the SR. Contrary to most beliefs, the CA can take parts from various other Nissan engines. So parts aren't that difficult to find. From what I've heard the RB isn't that bad in terms of throwing off the weight dist. But if your gonna go RB, your better off with the RB25 or RB26. The RB20 makes what 220hp. And SR will get you that much without a sweat, and your weight diff. wouldn't be affected. The KA is always a nice alternative as well. But like you said spitz, it would need extensive re-building to make it worthwhile.
|
Originally posted by Silviaspeed The CA is a good choice as an engine. It has a cast iron block, and yes with stock internals the CA can handle more boost. Up to 20psi. I believe the differences in the head that you were talking about rude have to do with the cams. The CA has 8 lobes per cylinder vs. the 4 lobes per cylinder of the SR. Contrary to most beliefs, the CA can take parts from various other Nissan engines. So parts aren't that difficult to find. From what I've heard the RB isn't that bad in terms of throwing off the weight dist. But if your gonna go RB, your better off with the RB25 or RB26. The RB20 makes what 220hp. And SR will get you that much without a sweat, and your weight diff. wouldn't be affected. The KA is always a nice alternative as well. But like you said spitz, it would need extensive re-building to make it worthwhile. |
I don't think the CA redlines at 9K stock, but with modification it can hit those revs. Take that S2000. :p
Thanks for pointing out the parts list there too. I think the flywheel off the KA works with the CA as well. There are other parts of course like I said from other Nissan engines, but I can't remember them all. :) |
wow, i never knew that the CA was such a bad ass engine... what cars did they come in?
|
All times are GMT -7. The time now is 04:29 AM. |
© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands